Kamfanonin rikodi na Sony Entertainment, Warner Music Group da Universal Music sun shigar da kara a Jamus game da mai ba da sabis na Uberspace, wanda ke ba da masauki ga gidan yanar gizon hukuma na aikin youtube-dl. Dangane da bukatar da aka aika daga kotu a baya don toshe youtube-dl, Uberspace ba ta amince da kashe rukunin yanar gizon ba kuma ta nuna rashin jituwa da ikirarin da ake yi. Masu shigar da kara sun nace cewa youtube-dl kayan aiki ne don keta haƙƙin mallaka kuma suna ƙoƙarin gabatar da ayyukan Uberspace a matsayin haɗaɗɗiyar rarraba software ba bisa ka'ida ba.
Shugaban Uberspace ya yi imanin cewa karar ba ta da tushe na doka, tunda youtube-dl ba ta ƙunshi damar ketare hanyoyin tsaro ba kuma kawai yana ba da dama ga abubuwan jama'a da aka riga aka samu akan YouTube. YouTube yana amfani da DRM don ƙuntata damar yin amfani da abun ciki mai lasisi, amma youtube-dl ba ya samar da kayan aiki don ɓoye bayanan rafukan bidiyo da aka ɓoye ta amfani da wannan fasaha. A cikin aikinsa, youtube-dl yana kama da wani ƙwararren masarrafa ne, amma babu wanda ke ƙoƙarin hanawa, misali, Firefox, saboda yana ba ku damar shiga bidiyo tare da kiɗa akan YouTube.
Masu gabatar da kara sun yi imanin cewa sauya abun ciki mai lasisi daga YouTube zuwa fayilolin da za a iya saukewa ba tare da izini ba ta shirin Youtube-dl ya saba wa doka, tunda yana ba ka damar ketare hanyoyin samun damar fasaha da YouTube ke amfani da su. Musamman ma, an ambaci ƙetare fasahar "cipher sa hannu" (rolling cipher), wanda, bisa ga masu gabatar da kara kuma bisa ga yanke shawara a cikin irin wannan shari'ar na Kotun Yanki na Hamburg, za a iya la'akari da ma'auni na kariya ta fasaha.
Abokan hamayyar sun yi imanin cewa wannan fasaha ba ta da alaƙa da kwafin hanyoyin kariya, ɓoyewa da kuma hana damar yin amfani da abun ciki mai kariya, tunda kawai sa hannu ne da ake iya gani na bidiyon YouTube, wanda ake iya karantawa a cikin lambar shafi kuma kawai ke gano bidiyon (za ku iya duba). wannan mai ganowa a cikin kowane mai bincike a cikin lambar shafi kuma sami hanyar zazzagewa).
Daga cikin da'awar da aka gabatar a baya, zamu iya kuma ambaci amfani a cikin Youtube-dl na hanyoyin haɗin kai zuwa abubuwan haɗin kai da ƙoƙarin zazzage su daga YouTube, amma ba za a iya ɗaukar wannan fasalin a matsayin cin zarafin haƙƙin mallaka ba, tunda an nuna hanyoyin haɗin cikin gwaje-gwajen naúrar ciki. waɗanda ba a bayyane ga masu amfani da ƙarshen ba, kuma lokacin da aka ƙaddamar da su, ba sa saukewa da rarraba duk abubuwan da ke ciki, amma kawai zazzage ƴan daƙiƙa na farko don manufar gwajin aikin.
A cewar lauyoyi na Gidauniyar Wutar Lantarki (EFF), aikin Youtube-dl bai keta doka ba tunda rufaffen sa hannun YouTube ba tsarin hana kwafi ba ne, kuma ana ɗaukar loda gwajin da kyau. A baya can, Ƙungiyar Ma'aikatar Rikodi ta Amurka (RIAA) ta riga ta yi ƙoƙari ta toshe Youtube-dl akan GitHub, amma masu goyon bayan aikin sun yi nasarar kalubalanci toshewa da sake samun damar shiga wurin ajiya.
A cewar lauyan Uberspace, shari’ar da ake ci gaba da yi wani yunkuri ne na samar da wani misali ko kuma wani hukunci na asali da za a iya amfani da shi nan gaba wajen matsa lamba kan wasu kamfanoni a irin wannan yanayi. A gefe guda, ka'idojin samar da sabis a YouTube sun nuna haramcin sauke kwafin zuwa tsarin gida, amma, a gefe guda, a Jamus, inda ake gudanar da shari'ar, akwai wata doka da ta ba masu amfani damar ƙirƙirar. kwafi don amfanin sirri.
Bugu da ƙari, YouTube yana biyan kuɗin sarauta don kiɗa, kuma masu amfani suna biyan kuɗin sarauta ga ƙungiyoyin haƙƙin mallaka don rama asarar da aka yi saboda haƙƙin ƙirƙira kwafi (irin waɗannan kuɗin sarauta suna cikin farashin wayoyin hannu da na'urorin ajiya don masu amfani). A lokaci guda kuma, kamfanonin rikodin, duk da kuɗin biyu, suna ƙoƙarin hana masu amfani da damar yin amfani da haƙƙin adana bidiyon YouTube a kan faifai.
source: budenet.ru