Rukunin Muse, wanda aka kafa ta Ultimate Guitar aikin kuma mai mallakar buɗaɗɗen ayyukan MusesCore da Audacity, sun dawo da ƙoƙarin rufe ma'ajiyar musescore-downloader, wanda ke haɓaka aikace-aikacen don saukar da bayanan kiɗa kyauta daga sabis ɗin musescore.com ba tare da izini ba. buƙatar shiga cikin rukunin yanar gizon kuma ba tare da haɗawa da biyan kuɗi na Musescore Pro ba. Har ila yau da'awar sun shafi ma'ajin musescore-dataset, wanda ya ƙunshi tarin kidan takarda da aka kwafi daga musescore.com. Duk da haka, Muse Group ba shi da wani abu a kan aikin LibreScore, wanda marubucin ɗaya ke haɓaka wani zaɓi na kyauta ga musescore.com, bisa tushen lambar aikace-aikacen MuseScore, wanda aka rarraba a ƙarƙashin lasisin GPL.
Wakilan Rukunin Muse sun tambayi marubucin don son rai ya share musescore-downloader da musescore-dataset ma'aji. Wurin ajiya na farko ya ƙunshi aikace-aikacen da ke ba ka damar zazzage kowane abun ciki daga sabis na musescore.com kyauta ta hanyar samun damar API na ciki. Ma'ajiyar tana ƙarƙashin rufewa saboda musescore-downloader ba bisa ka'ida ba yana ƙetare tsarin kariyar haƙƙin mallaka (babu korafe-korafe game da samun damar samun abun ciki na jama'a akan musescore.com). Wurin ajiya na biyu, musescore-dataset, yana rarraba kwafin ayyukan da aka ba da lasisi daga masu buga kiɗan ba bisa ka'ida ba. A cikin yanayin musescore-dataset, matsalolin sun fi tsanani kuma ana iya la'akari da su a matsayin laifi (cin zarafin haƙƙin mallaka na gangan tare da niyyar aikata laifi).
Marubucin ma'ajiyar matsala ya ki share ma'ajiyar kuma kamfanin Muse Group ya fuskanci matsala mai wuya. A gefe guda, akwai barazanar daina wanzuwar sabis na musescore.com, kuma a gefe guda, damar da za ta gurgunta rayuwar mutum. Hanya mafi sauƙi ita ce shigar da lauyoyi da aika buƙatun DMCA na hukuma zuwa GitHub don toshe ma'ajiyar, amma ƙungiyar Muse ta yanke shawarar ba za ta yi amfani da irin waɗannan ayyukan ba, amma don yin shawarwari ba bisa ƙa'ida ba bayan sun gano cewa Wenzheng Tang, mai haɓakawa. Ma'ajiyar matsala, wanda ya bar kasar Sin saboda dalilai na siyasa, kuma idan aka samu matsala a cikin doka, zai fuskanci soke takardar izinin zama da kuma korar shi, sannan za a yi masa tursasa a gida saboda cin mutuncin gwamnatin kasar Sin.
A gefe guda na ma'auni shine yiwuwar rushe matsayin da aka samu tare da mawallafin kiɗa. Da farko, an buga duk abubuwan da ke ciki a kan MuseScore ta masu sa kai kyauta kuma ba tare da ƙuntatawa ba, amma sai al'umma sun fara tsananta wa masu haƙƙin mallaka kuma masu ƙirƙirar MuseScore sun yi ƙoƙari mai yawa don tsayawa kan ruwa da adana shafin. Matsalar ita ce haƙƙin rubuta aikin kiɗan zuwa bayanin kula da tsari na mai haƙƙin mallaka ne, ba tare da la’akari da wanda ya yi rubutun ko tsari ba.
Farashin ci gaba da aiki na MuseScore.com shine lasisin mashahuran maki ga kamfanoni kamar Alfred, EMI da Sony, da kuma ƙuntatawa ta hanyar tsarin biyan kuɗi. Rukunin Muse ana buƙatar doka don tabbatar da kariyar haƙƙin mallaka na ayyukan kiɗan masu lasisi, kuma kasancewar madaidaicin saukar da abun ciki mara iyaka yana haifar da barazana ga wanzuwar sabis ɗin.
Rikicin da marubucin musescore-downloader yana gudana tun daga Fabrairu 2020. An lura cewa lokacin tunani ya kusan ƙarewa kuma nan ba da jimawa ba za a yanke shawara. Har ila yau, masu riƙe haƙƙin mallaka na iya ɗaukar matakan da suka saba wa karya a kowane lokaci.
Matsayin marubucin musescore-downloader shine ya yi amfani da daidaitattun API ɗin da aka rubuta a bainar jama'a a cikin shirinsa, bayanin wanda aka cire daga gidan yanar gizon musescore.com bayan an ƙirƙiri aikace-aikacen. Bugu da ƙari, marubucin mai amfani da mai saukewa yana ganin ba daidai ba ne cewa samun damar yin amfani da wallafe-wallafen da masu sha'awa suka shirya kuma an fara buga su a cikin jama'a kyauta kawai ga masu biyan kuɗi, yayin da Muse Group ba shi da haƙƙin abun ciki da masu amfani suka shirya ( masu amfani ba su mallaki haƙƙin waƙar takarda na ayyukan wasu mutane ba, tunda masu haƙƙin mallaka mawaƙa ne da masu buga kiɗan).
source: budenet.ru