A cikin shekarun da DxO Mark ke daraja duk kyamarori da wayoyi a cikin wani tsari, ra'ayin yin gwajin kwatancen da kanku yana da ɗan ƙaranci. A daya bangaren, me zai hana? Bugu da ƙari, a lokaci ɗaya muna da dukkanin wayoyin hannu na zamani na zamani a hannunmu - kuma mun tura su tare.
Abu daya: riga a cikin aiwatar da shirya wannan kayan, ya fito , wanda kawai ba shi da lokacin da zai dace da wannan showdown, don haka an tilasta mana fitar da mai yuwuwar lashe gasar daga cikin ma'auni. Hoton na Huawei Mate 20 Pro ya ɗauki wurinsa.
Ba mu bayyana dalla-dalla game da halayen fasaha na wayowin komai da ruwan ba har ma da kyamarorinsu - don wannan akwai sake dubawa da aka buga game da kowane na'urorin da aka gabatar a cikin gwajin kwatankwacin:
- ;
- ;
- ;
- ;
- .
Amma har yanzu ya zama dole a gano wasu mahimman abubuwa. Duk wayowin komai da ruwan da aka gabatar anan suna da kyamarori waɗanda suka bambanta a cikin aiki da ƙirar fasaha. Google Pixel 3 XL ita ce kawai wayar kamara guda ɗaya wacce ba ta ba da ƙarin kusurwar kallo ko zuƙowa ta gani ba, software kawai. IPhone Xs Max wayar kyamara ce mai dual, kyamarar ta biyu wacce ke ba da zuƙowa na gani 9x. Huawei, Samsung da Xiaomi sun ba da tsarin kyamara uku tare da bambance-bambance daban-daban na harbi mai faɗi da zuƙowa - ninki biyu don Mi 10 da Galaxy S20 +, sau uku don Mate 3 Pro. Bugu da ƙari, duk suna sanye da yanayin hoto na musamman tare da ikon iya ɓata bango a hankali - wannan shiri ne na wajibi a yau, amma kawai Samsung, Huawei da Xiaomi suna haɓaka hoto ta amfani da "hankali na wucin gadi". Zuwa wani lokaci, HDR+ yana taka rawa iri ɗaya a cikin Google Pixel XNUMX XL, amma babu wata ma'ana a kwatanta waɗannan hanyoyin gaba-gaba. Apple iPhone, kamar yadda ya saba, yana ɓoye duk saitunan daga mai amfani, yana yanke masa cikakken komai da kansa. Don haka, mun gudanar da gwaje-gwajen a cikin yanayin atomatik kuma tare da saitunan asali - amma tare da yanayin AI an kashe don duk wayowin komai da ruwan da ke ba da izinin hakan.
Gwaji
Za mu kimanta sakamako bisa ma'auni daban-daban a cikin gwaje-gwaje daban-daban, amma mahimman abubuwan zasu zama kaifi da daki-daki. Bugu da ƙari, sakamakon yana shafar daidaitaccen saitin bayyanar da ma'auni na fari. A cikin kowane gwajin, wayar hannu na iya ci maki 1, 2, 3, 4 ko 5, gwargwadon matsayinta a cikin katin rahoton ra'ayi (wuri na farko - maki 5, wuri na biyar - maki 1). Na'urar da mafi yawan maki za a kira mafi kyau.
Ba za a iya yin watsi da kasancewar ma'auni mai faɗi a cikin ƙima na ƙarshe kawai saboda mai amfani yana da ƙarin dama yayin amfani da shi. Don kimanta aikinta, an gudanar da gwajin daban tare da mahalarta uku - wanda ya ci nasara ya sami maki 3, wayar salula wacce ta dauki matsayi na biyu ta sami maki 2, matsayi na uku ya sami maki 1. Saboda haka, kowannensu ya sami ƙarin maki a cikin cikakken rahoton katin rahoto.
Tun da ba mu gudanar da binciken mai amfani ba, tsarkin gwajin ba shi da mahimmanci a nan - tsarin hotuna koyaushe iri ɗaya ne, a cikin jerin haruffa.
shimfidar titi
Wuri mai sauƙi, na asali inda ainihin abin da kyamara ta fi mayar da hankali shine daki-daki, faffadan kewayo mai ƙarfi, da ingancin launi.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
Yin harbi tare da babban kamara, ba tare da amfani da fadi-tashi ko yanayin zuƙowa ba, an saita saitunan tsoho a ko'ina (Huawei na iya amfani da "ainihin HDR", da Pixel 3 XL - HDR +). Anan kowa yana aiki da kyau - wannan shine ainihin wurin da koda na'urorin kasafin kuɗi yakamata su samar da hoto na yau da kullun.
Hoton iPhone ya dubi mafi dadi - launuka suna da ɗan sanyi, amma ya dubi cikakke; daki-daki yana da kyau. Galaxy ɗan rawaya ne, hoton yana da haske sosai, ƙasa da bambanci, amma ya dace da matakin. Pixel ba ya amfani da sarrafa kayan sa na mallakarsa har zuwa cikar sa, kuma inuwa ba ta da cikakkun bayanai. Mun kuma lura da jajayen launuka. Huawei, duk da babban matsayinsa, yana samar da hoto mai ɗan sabulu tare da gazawar inuwa da launuka masu dumi sosai. Xiaomi yana da launuka na halitta, amma in ba haka ba babu wani abu da za a yi alfahari da shi: kewayon mai ƙarfi yana da rauni kuma daki-daki ba shi da iyaka.
Apple iPhone Xs Max - maki 5;
Samsung Galaxy S10 + - maki 4;
Google Pixel 3 XL - maki 3;
Huawei Mate 20 Pro - maki 2;
Xiaomi Mi 9 – 1 aya.
Harbi a cikin ciki tare da daidaitaccen kusurwar kallo
Wannan lamari ne da ya fi dacewa da wahala - ingantaccen aiki tare da ma'aunin fari, daki-daki mai inganci tare da rage amo mai kyau kuma ba kawai fa'ida mai ƙarfi ba, har ma da ingantaccen aiki na na'urorin gani tare da maɓuɓɓuka masu yawa na hasken wucin gadi suna da mahimmanci anan.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
A cikin wannan yanayin, Huawei's penchant don sautunan dumi suna aiki don fa'idar wannan wayar - launuka suna kama da na halitta. Sabulun da muka lura lokacin harbin filin titi ya tafi wani wuri - an bayyana cikakkun bayanai. Samsung ya sake nuna dabi'a ga ɗimbin ƙwaƙƙwalwa, amma idan har ƙarfin ƙarfin yana da kyau, wannan baya cutar da hoton. Launuka sun fi sanyi fiye da yadda ya kamata. Xiaomi yana aiki a cikin hanya mai kama da wannan labarin - babban aiki mai inganci. IPhone, wanda launukansa yayi kyau akan nunin wayar da kanta, akan allon na'urar tantancewa yana samar da hoton da ya riga ya yi sanyi, kuma ana bayyana bambanci tsakanin ƙasa mai dumi da saman sanyi. Pixel shima yana da kyau sosai, amma ya yi hasarar ga masu fafatawa daki-daki da kewayo mai ƙarfi (ba a haɗa HDR+ a cikin aikin ba).
- Huawei Mate 20 Pro - maki 5;
- Samsung Galaxy S10 + - maki 4;
- Xiaomi Mi 9 - maki 3;
- Apple iPhone Xs Max - maki 2;
- Google Pixel 3 XL - maki 1.
Harbi a ciki tare da zuƙowa
Akwai bayanai da yawa anan. Wayoyin hannu guda uku suna sanye da zuƙowa na gani 9x (Xiaomi Mi 10, Samsung Galaxy S20+, iPhone Xs Max), ɗayan yana sanye da zuƙowa na gani mai girman 3x (Huawei Mate XNUMX Pro), kuma Google Pixel XNUMX XL yana iya nuna iyawar software ɗin sa kawai. tare da zuƙowa na dijital.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
Kuma sakamakon ba zato ba tsammani. Pixel, tare da zuƙowa na dijital, yana nuna kyakkyawan aiki mai inganci - hoton kusan baya rasa tsabta, an daidaita kaifin kwane-kwane da kyau, kuma babu "sabulu". Hoton yayi duhu kadan. IPhone, duk da haka, ya fi kyau: mai arziki amma launuka masu gaskiya, ma'auni mai kyau na fari, kyakkyawan daki-daki, ƙarfin ƙarfin ƙarfi. Samsung ba shi da kasa da duka biyun a cikin kaifi, amma yana nuna ɗan ban mamaki, fassarar launi mara kyau. Xiaomi ya dan yi kasa da kai ta fuskar kaifi da daidaiton fallasa, kuma hoton kodadde ne. Da kyau, Huawei tare da zuƙowa sau uku yana yin mafi muni a cikin wannan gasa: ƙarancin daki-daki da aka haɗa tare da ma'auni mara kyau ba su bar wata dama ga wannan ƙirƙirar injiniyan Sinawa ba.
- Apple iPhone Xs Max - maki 5;
- Google Pixel 3 XL - maki 4;
- Samsung Galaxy S10 + - maki 3;
- Xiaomi Mi 9-2 maki;
- Huawei Mate 20 Pro - maki 1.
Yin harbi a cikin ciki tare da na'urorin gani mai faɗin kusurwa
Na'urori uku ne kawai masu na'urorin gani masu faɗin kusurwa suka shiga cikin wannan gasa: Huawei Mate 20 Pro, Samsung Galaxy S10+ da Xiaomi Mi 9. Dukansu Apple da Google sun tsallake shi kuma ba sa samun maki.
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||
Samsung yana da fa'ida mai sauƙin gani a nan - ruwan tabarau mai faɗi na wannan wayar kawai yana da kusurwar kallo mai faɗi, wanda, haɗe tare da ingantaccen aiki tare da ɓarna na sarari (wannan har yanzu ana iya inganta shi a cikin saitunan) da launuka na al'ada, yana sanya shi a ciki. wuri na farko. Kyamarar SHU ta Galaxy ba ta da autofocus, amma a cikin yanayi irin wannan ba kome ba. Huawei kuma yana da kyau sosai, amma yana ɗan ƙasa kaɗan a kusan dukkanin bangarorin, sai dai kasancewar autofocus (wanda ba ya shafar hoto ta kowace hanya a cikin wannan yanayin) - duka a cikin daki-daki, da kuma a kusurwar kallo, da kuma cikin fassarar launi. Hakanan Xiaomi na iya faranta wa mai amfani da autofocus a cikin wannan yanayin, amma hoton da kansa ya fi muni - launuka masu sanyi da sautin kodadde.
- Samsung Galaxy S10 + - maki 3;
- Huawei Mate 20 Pro - maki 2;
- Xiaomi Mi 9 – 1 aya.
Harbin dare
Makirci mafi wahala ga kowace wayar salula shine saboda ƙananan girman firikwensin, babu kyamarar wayar hannu da za ta iya samun haske mai yawa kamar ko da kyamarar batu-da-harbi na yau da kullun. Abin da ya rage shi ne a dogara ga daidaitawar gani, sarrafa software mai inganci da na'urar gani mai ƙarfi, wanda duk wayoyin hannu da ke shiga gwaji za su iya yin alfahari da su. Tabbas, Samsung Galaxy S10 + tare da buɗewar dangi na babban ruwan tabarau na ƒ/1,5 ya fice musamman. Ba mu gwada harbi da zuƙowa ko ruwan tabarau mai faɗi a cikin wannan labarin ba. Hakanan ya shafi yanayin dare na musamman ta amfani da fa'idodi da yawa - mun bincika duk wayoyin hannu da ke da su (Google Pixel 3 XL, Huawei Mate 20 Pro, Xiaomi Mi 9), amma sun bar sakamakon daga gasar.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
Huawei Mate 20 Pro, duk da rashin na'urar firikwensin monochrome na mallaka (yanzu matrix tare da tace RYYB ana iya la'akari da shi na mallakar mallaka), yana nuna harbi mai inganci - ma'aunin fari na al'ada, hoto mai bambanta; Wayar hannu tana ƙoƙari sosai don haɓaka kaifi ta hanyar wucin gadi, amma wannan baya haifar da mummunan sakamako. Samsung yana samar da hoto mai ɗan ƙaramin sabulu - wannan sabon abu ne ga na'urorin Koriya, waɗanda suka daɗe suna "sananniya" don yin aiki sosai tare da ƙwanƙwasa. Amma babu gunaguni game da ma'anar launi da ma'auni na fari. IPhone yana harbi da kusan daki-daki iri ɗaya da Samsung, amma yana da ƙasa da haɓakar launi - kamara a bayyane yake "kore." Xiaomi yana da kaifi mai kyau, wanda yake da kyau idan aka yi la'akari da na'urar ba ta da na'urar daidaitawa ta gani, amma akwai matsala tare da kewayon ƙarfi - wuce gona da iri ana iya gani sosai. Wayar Google tare da saitunan tsoho suna haifar da hoto mai rauni - manyan abubuwan da ba a bayyana ba kuma a lokaci guda kasancewar “sabulu” a bayyane da hayaniya a cikin hoton: “pixel” a zahiri yana roƙon kunna yanayin dare na musamman.
- Huawei Mate 20 Pro - maki 5;
- Samsung Galaxy S10 + - maki 4;
- Apple iPhone Xs Max - maki 3;
- Xiaomi Mi 9-2 maki;
- Google Pixel 3 XL - maki 1.
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||
Amma lokacin da yanayin dare ya kunna, wanda ke buƙatar daƙiƙa 3-5 na nutsuwa daga mai daukar hoto, Pixel ya canza - ba za mu ce ya zarce Huawei a cikin “na asali” hoton dare ba, amma rata daga kanta a yanayin al'ada shine. muhimmanci sosai. Huawei yana samar da hoto mai haske sosai, amma yana ƙoƙari sosai don daidaita hoton - ya zama sabulu fiye da lokacin harbi ta tsohuwa. Xiaomi yana aiki maras tabbas a cikin wannan yanayin: ba koyaushe yana yiwuwa a sami hoto mai inganci a karon farko ba, amma lokacin da yake aiki, komai yana cikin tsari - hoto mai haske, mai kaifi, amma tare da fassarar launi ba daidai ba (akwai son zuciya ga sautunan ja).
Macro
A wannan yanayin, Huawei Mate 20 Pro yana da fa'ida ta dabi'a - yanayin "super macro" tare da kunna kyamarar kusurwa mai faɗi tare da mafi ƙarancin nisa mai nisa na 2,5 cm. Sauran mahalarta gwajin suna aiki tare da babban kyamara kuma kusan nisa mai da hankali iri ɗaya. A cikin wannan yanayin, mafi mahimmancin abubuwa shine kaifi da ingancin ma'anar launi.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
Huawei ya lashe wannan gasar ba tare da fada ba - kawai saboda gaskiyar cewa tare da taimakonsa zaku iya harba kusan macro na gaske. Kuma a sa'an nan yana da kyawawan m fada. Google Pixel yana samar da launuka masu sanyi kaɗan, amma ya fi sauran masu fafatawa (sai dai Mate, ba shakka) dangane da kaifi. IPhone na Apple na iya da'awar matsayi na biyu a wannan gasa - ɗan ƙaramin launi daban-daban (wayar wayar Apple tana iya zama "kore"), kuma idan ta yi ƙasa da kai, tana da kaɗan. Amma Pixel har yanzu ya ɗan fi kyau. Samsung kuma yana nuna kaifi mai kyau, amma ba ya jure wa bayyanarwa da kyau - a cikin salon sa, yana ɗaga haske sama da matakin da ake buƙata, amma a nan wannan bai dace da hoton ba. Xiaomi shima yana da macro mai aiki sosai, amma ta kowane fanni ya dan kasa kasa da masu fafatawa - duka cikin kaifi da kuma canza launi.
- Huawei Mate 20 Pro - maki 5;
- Google Pixel 3 XL - maki 4;
- Apple iPhone Xs Max - maki 3;
- Samsung Galaxy S10 + - maki 2;
- Xiaomi Mi 9 – 1 aya.
source: 3dnews.ru