Mutongo wedare pamusoro pekusava pamutemo kwekubvisa mamwe mamiriro kune rezinesi reAGPL

Iyo Open Source Initiative (OSI), iyo inoongorora marezinesi ekutevedzera Open Source maitiro, yakaburitsa ongororo yemutongo wedare panyaya yaipokana nePureThink ine chekuita nekutyorwa kwehungwaru hweNeo4j Inc.

Ngatiyeukei kuti PureThink yakagadzira forogo yeNeo4j purojekiti, iyo yakatanga kupihwa pasi peiyo AGPLv3 rezinesi, asi ikazokamurwa kuita yemahara Community edition uye yekutengeserana vhezheni yeNeo4 EE. Kune iyo vhezheni yekutengeserana, mamwe "Commons Clause" mamiriro akawedzerwa kune iyo AGPL zvinyorwa, zvichidzikamisa kushandiswa mumasevhisi emakore. Sezvo rezinesi reAGPLv3 riine clause inobvumira kubviswa kwezvimwe zvirambidzo zvinotyora kodzero dzakapihwa nerezinesi reAGPL, PureThink yakagadzira forogo yayo yeONgDB zvichibva paNeo4 EE product code, asi ndokuigovera pasi perezinesi reAGPL renguva dzose ndokurishambadza se yakavhurika zvachose shanduro yeNeo4 EE.

Dare rakazivisa zvisiri pamutemo kubviswa kwemamwe mamiriro akawedzerwa neNeo4j Inc kune chinyorwa cherezinesi reAGPL muforogo, nekuda kwekuti shanduko yezvinyorwa zverezinesi yakaitwa nemuridzi wekodzero yezvivakwa kune kodhi uye. zviito zvake zvinongosvika pakuendeswa kweprojekiti kune rezinesi idzva remuridzi rakagadzirwa pahwaro hweAGPL.

Dare rakabvumirana nemumhan'ari kuti chirevo cheAGPL chine chekuita nekugona kubvisa mamwe mamiriro chinoshanda kune ane rezinesi chete, uye mushandisi ndiye ane rezinesi anofanirwa kutevedzera clause 7 ne10, iyo inorambidza muridzi werezinesi kuunza zvimwe zvirambidzo, asi kwete. kurambidza mupi werezenisi kuita kudaro. Chero imwe dudziro yezvikamu izvi ingapesana nemisimboti yemutemo wekodzero, izvo zvinopa vanyori kodzero yakasarudzika yekupa rezinesi chigadzirwa chavo pasi pemitemo yesarudzo yavo.

Panguva imwecheteyo, vanyori verezinesi reAGPL vakaisa chirevo chinobvumira kubviswa kwezvimwe zvirambidzo (ona chinyorwa 73) zvakanyanya seyero yekupokana nekushungurudzwa nevaridzi vekodzero dzekodhi, sekuwedzera zvimwe zvinodiwa zvinorambidza kushandiswa kwekutengesa. Asi dare harina kubvumirana nechinzvimbo ichi uye, zvichibva pane zvakabuda munyaya yakambofungidzirwa kuti “Neo4j Inc v. Graph Foundation”, rakasarudza kuti chirevo chiri murezinesi reAGPL kupikisa kuiswa kwezvimwe zvirambidzo chinoshanda kune zviito zve. vashandisi (vane marezinesi), uye varidzi vekodzero dzezvivakwa kune kodhi (vanopa marezinesi) vakasununguka kupihwa rezenisi.

Panguva imwecheteyo, sepakutanga, rezinesi rinogona kungoshandurwa kuita kodhi nyowani, uye iyo yekare vhezheni yekodhi iyo yakambovhurwa pasi pe AGPL inoramba iripo pasi perezinesi rekare. Avo. Mupomerwi anogona kugadzira forogo yekodhi pasi peiyo AGPL yakachena mudunhu rezinesi risati rashandurwa nemunyori, asi kuisa forogo pakodhi nyowani ine rezinesi rakashandurwa, kuitora sekodhi pasi pe AGPL yakachena, hazvitenderwe.

Source: opennet.ru